Choosing a journal is a publishing decision, not a final formatting task. This workflow helps you turn a broad list of academic journals into a defensible shortlist by checking scope, indexing, audience, costs, review expectations, access policies, and submission requirements. It also includes a comparison table and two email templates you can reuse before and after journal submission.
Overview
The right journal is the one that can credibly evaluate, publish, and reach the audience for your manuscript. A prestigious title is not automatically the best fit, and a fast review promise should not outweigh questions about editorial standards or journal legitimacy.
Begin with the manuscript rather than with a ranking. Write down its central question, methods, main contribution, discipline, article type, approximate word count, and intended readers. Then identify journals that have recently published research articles with similar questions, methods, or audiences. Your literature review, reference list, library databases, and a reliable journal finder can all provide starting points.
Separate essential requirements from preferences. Essential requirements might include accepting your article type, covering your subject area, and being suitable for your institution or funder. Preferences might include a short review period, open access, a particular quartile, or a transfer option. This distinction prevents one attractive feature from hiding a serious mismatch.
Indexing and ranking information should be verified from the relevant database or publisher source. A journal may be listed in Scopus, Web of Science, another discipline-specific index, or none of these. Do not treat a search-engine result, an unverified badge, or a third-party claim as conclusive evidence of current coverage. Quartiles and other indicators can vary by database, subject category, and reporting year, so record the source and date beside every value.
Checklist by scenario
Scenario 1: Building an initial shortlist
- Define the manuscript. Record the research question, contribution, methods, article type, length, language, and likely readership.
- Find comparable journals. Review the journals publishing the most relevant research articles in your references and recent database searches.
- Check scope and article type. Read the aims and scope, accepted formats, subject categories, and exclusions. A topical keyword match alone is not enough.
- Review recent content. Examine a sample of recent articles for methodological level, terminology, article length, and the kinds of contributions the journal actually publishes.
- Record evidence. Save the journal webpage, indexing page, author guidelines, fee page, and date checked in your comparison table.
Scenario 2: Comparing credible candidates
Use the following table as a spreadsheet structure. Add a notes column for links, dates, and questions. Avoid filling a cell with a guess; use not stated or to verify when the journal does not provide clear information.
| Comparison field | Journal A | Journal B | Journal C |
|---|---|---|---|
| Scope and manuscript fit | |||
| Article type accepted | |||
| Scopus status and date checked | |||
| Web of Science status and date checked | |||
| Impact or quartile information, database and year | |||
| Article processing charge and currency | |||
| Waivers or discounts and eligibility | |||
| Median review or decision time, if stated | |||
| Open-access route and license options | |||
| Copyright or self-archiving policy | |||
| Transfer option and conditions | |||
| Editorial board and contact details checked | |||
| Predatory-journal checks completed | |||
| Final fit score and reason |
Scenario 3: Prioritising the shortlist
Score each candidate against your own priorities, rather than copying a universal ranking. For example, use a simple scale from 1 to 5 for scope fit, audience fit, indexing suitability, transparency, affordability, review expectations, and access compatibility. Give essential criteria a pass-or-fail status before calculating a total. A journal with a high overall score should still be removed if it does not accept your manuscript type or cannot meet a required funder or institutional condition.
Scenario 4: Sending a presubmission inquiry
A presubmission inquiry is useful when the scope or article type is genuinely uncertain. Keep it brief and do not send the full manuscript unless the journal specifically requests it.
Subject: Presubmission inquiry: [proposed manuscript title]
Dear [Editor or Editorial Office],
I am considering submitting a [article type] titled “[manuscript title]” to [journal name]. The manuscript examines [one-sentence research question] using [brief description of method or data]. Its main contribution is [one-sentence contribution].
Could you advise whether this topic and article type appear to fit the journal’s current scope? The manuscript is approximately [word count] words and is not under consideration elsewhere. I would be pleased to provide an abstract or additional details if helpful.
Thank you for your time.
Kind regards,
[name]
[affiliation]
[ORCID, if appropriate]
Scenario 5: Choosing an alternative after rejection
Do not automatically submit to the next journal on an old list. First classify the decision: out of scope, editorial rejection, rejection after review, or invitation to revise. Apply useful reviewer comments, confirm that the manuscript still fits the alternative journal, and update the table with current fees, policies, and review information.
Scenario 6: Resubmitting after revision
Use the journal’s instructions for revised manuscripts and response documents. A concise cover note can accompany the files:
Subject: Revised submission: [manuscript title], [manuscript ID]
Dear [Editor],
Thank you for the opportunity to revise our manuscript, “[manuscript title].” We have addressed the editorial and reviewer comments in the revised manuscript and accompanying response document. Major changes include [briefly list two or three changes]. All authors have approved the revised submission, and the manuscript is not under consideration elsewhere.
We appreciate your consideration.
Kind regards,
[corresponding author name]
[affiliation and contact details]
What to double-check
- Indexing: Verify Scopus or Web of Science coverage in the database or official source, and record the date checked. Coverage can change.
- Metrics: Identify the database, subject category, and year for any impact or quartile information. Do not compare unlike indicators as though they were equivalent.
- Article processing charges: Check the current fee page, taxes or currency notes, optional charges, waivers, discounts, and the point at which a fee becomes payable. If no fee is stated, confirm rather than assume that publication is free.
- Review time: Distinguish editorial screening, first decision, peer review, and total publication time. A journal’s stated median or typical time is not a guarantee for an individual manuscript.
- Open access: Check whether the journal is fully open access, hybrid, or subscription-based, and review available licenses, repository rules, embargoes, and funder requirements.
- Transfer options: Determine whether a transfer is optional, whether reviewer reports move with the manuscript, and whether fees or new formatting requirements apply.
- Legitimacy: Check the publisher identity, editorial board, contact information, peer-review description, archiving arrangements, and membership or indexing claims. Use a structured predatory-journal checklist rather than relying on a single list or badge.
- Submission compatibility: Confirm word limits, reference style, data or ethics requirements, anonymisation rules, file formats, and declarations before investing time in formatting.
Common mistakes
Choosing by quartile alone. A Q1 label may be attractive, but subject fit, audience, article type, and realistic contribution matter more than a single ranking signal.
Using outdated fee or review information. Publisher pages change. A figure saved during a previous project may not apply to the current submission.
Confusing indexing with quality assurance. Indexing is useful evidence of coverage, but it is not a substitute for reading the journal’s policies, recent content, and editorial information.
Trusting an unverified predatory-journal list. Lists can be incomplete or outdated. Investigate the journal’s current identity and policies, and record what you checked.
Sending the same inquiry everywhere. A generic message suggests weak fit. Mention the manuscript’s question, contribution, article type, and one reason you believe the journal may be appropriate.
Ignoring practical constraints. Confirm whether all authors can meet data, ethics, licensing, language, and publication-cost requirements before submission.
When to revisit
Use this workflow for every new manuscript, not just when submitting for the first time. Rebuild the shortlist when the research question, article type, target audience, or funder requirements change. After a rejection, update the table before selecting an alternative rather than relying on the previous decision.
Set a maintenance schedule for any journal comparison guide. Update Scopus and Web of Science indexing status and journal quartiles annually after release, using the applicable database year and recording the date. Refresh article processing charges, waivers, and discount information quarterly or immediately before submission. Recheck median review or decision times and editorial board details every six to twelve months, or after a publisher announcement. Recheck predatory-journal warning signs, licensing terms, and self-archiving policies during major publisher or industry policy changes.
Before acting, complete this short final check:
- Does the journal clearly fit the manuscript and article type?
- Have indexing, metrics, fees, access policies, and review information been verified recently?
- Can the authors meet every technical, ethical, financial, and licensing requirement?
- Has the journal passed a legitimacy review based on multiple signals?
- Has the corresponding author saved the current guidelines and prepared a tailored submission or presubmission message?
Keep the completed table with the manuscript files. It becomes useful evidence when planning future submissions, explaining a journal choice to collaborators, or selecting the next destination after a rejection.